Why is art expensive?

Here is an interesting article on why artwork is expensive.My comments are marked in red...

____

Suppose you see a painting for sale for $1890, and you think to yourself, “Good grief, that’s a lot of money. Why on earth does it cost so much?” Well, you've got to think of it in terms of what goes into producing such a thing.

Here’s an approximate breakdown of that $1890:

* Materials: canvas, primer, paint, frame supplies, and hardware: $200

This shows that the entire raw material supply system should also be changed to bring down the cost

* Overhead: Cost of tools, easel, computer, sketchbooks, camera, brushes, desk, chair, office supplies, file cabinets, shelving, rent or mortgage for studio space, phone, Internet, and utilities for studio, work truck for transporting art and materials, car insurance, gas, business licenses, taxes, etc., ad infinitum:  $250

Not much can be changed here

* Gallery

commission: 40%-50%. 40-50% margin is way too high. There should be a better way for art works to reach the person. Galleries are set up in high end areas. So rentals are very high. They have to charge this much amount to pay their rents and overhead costs.

* The artist's time - After I subtract the cost of materials and overhead from my cut of the sale ($940), this is what is left as payment for my time:

$500

So this is the real value of the artwork. Rest everything (excluding some component of the first one - materials) is over head. There should be a way to bring down this overhead. 

It takes on an avg, 20 hrs to do the painting. For this painting, I end up getting about $25/hour. To put that in perspective, graphic designers charge $60-$75, a good attorney or therapist may charge more than $100.

So, what is the core of the problem? I believe it is just selling only one artwork of a kind. So, every new artwork, he has to put all his effort again in creating it. Then again it will be expensive. And more over around 90% of art works won't be sold for an artist. So 10% should bear the cost of those 90% unsold artworks. Then why not duplicate and reduce the cost. This is where DAW comes into picture. We make multiple copies of the artworks and sell those at a lower price point. This way we increase the target market for artworks and thus sell many artworks (Without any time and effort of artist). This generates additional revenue for the artist. So, an artist is getting more than what he was earning initially.

Note: The core of the blog is taken from this article: http://www.articlesbase.com/visual-art-articles/why-art-is-expensive-704229.html

Economic principles behind Digital Art Works

What is Digital Art Works - Digital Art Works is into selling global art at affordable rates. This looks like a very simple concept till one finds out the underlying factors behind the launch of this seemingly simple concept.

Many (in fact every) products in the world go through a 4 stage life cycle - Niche & Status Symbol, Niche & Fashionable Item, Commodity & Fashionable Item, Pure Commodity, Death.Take any product and look at it through this 4 stage life cycle lens and you understand how a product moves in its life time. I will take a classic example of mobiles to explain it in the Indian context. 

In the late 90's having a Black & White bulky Nokia phone was considered a status symbol. Only the uber rich were able to afford it and rest others envy them for their mobile phone. Later on due to technology advances, cost came down and the product moves from Niche & Status to Niche & Fashionable Item. Now the upper middle class were able to afford this mobile phone and the mobile phone became wide prevalent. At this stage the uber rich moved to a new phone discarding this one. And then it became commodity & fashionable item. By then, it became accessible to even middle class and it became wide prevalent. Middle class started flaunting it among the fellow middle class people. After a few years, i guess by 2005, it became a pure commodity. Poor, old and 'I don't care how a mobile phone looks' people were the only ones using it. By 2009, it was discontinued and we hardly see that bulky Nokia phone in the market. 

This happens to every product. Even for cricket which is once hailed the rich man's sport. And cars - Before Ford invented Model T, cars were rich men thing. After Ford's Model T, it became a common man's thing. Even in India, it is now becoming a common man's thing. People like Henry Ford, Richard Branson envision the need for moving the product from Niche segment to mass segment and in the process revolutionize the entire industry. We are in a way now trying to emulate Henry Ford in the field of art.

There are some products which are always maintained as the rich man's object. Brands like Louis Vuitton, Chanel ... they maintain their position by keeping the prices high and by maintaining artificial scarcity. With the current technology they can make LV a common man's bag but they don't. In fact, i heard few years back LV had put a condition that only one bag for one Japanese customer may be during Japan's roaring 80s. And the other one is natural resources. By nature, they are limited and thus their price is high. But also it is an open secret that DTC maintains artificial scarcity by stocking diamonds in its warehouses to maintain the price.

With this brief background, lets see how art is positioned in the market. Art is always maintained as mainly a rich man's thing by maintaining an artificial high price for the art work.  Nobody knows how the artwork is priced. Middle class envy those rich buying the art thinking they are sophisticated. Galleries are very uninviting for the normal person. But should art be only for rich. A thorough study revealed that art appreciation doesn't require richness and art can be a common man's thing. So effectively increase the supply of artwork and bring down the price of artwork. We explored ways to increase the supply and found one great solution (kudos to the technological advances). We thought we got the killer application and reached artists to get the artworks. But to our utter dismay, none of the artists seemed interested in our concept. They haven't given us the digital rights of the artworks. And upon exploration we realized that they are too deeply rooted into those preconceived notion that art should be sold expensive that they don't want to sell it cheap. We tried to convince them by showing the comparision between price and scale. Lower price can be compensated with higher scale. But few seemed convinced.

And also the marginal cost of selling a print for the artist is zero. He just creates the artwork and thats it. Where are his marginal revenue is very high. It also didn't seem to convince many artists. Of course, the fact that ours is a startup made them skeptical about this entire thing. But we wanted to prove them that this works and we are looking forward for a day when artists come to us and give us the artworks for the sale. 

There is a saying 'Nothing stops the idea whose time has come'. We believe the time has come for this idea and we want to make it happen...

Happy Ugadi

Digital Art Works wishes you all a very happy and prosperous Ugadi. May this new year brings loads and loads of happiness to all of you....

Digital Art Works Team

An event at HITEX

Dear All,

      Last weekend there was an event at HITEX, Hyderabad organized by IT/ITes Association of AP to showcase the start ups from Hyderabad. We had put up a demo stall to showcase our start up. We are very glad to inform you all that we received tremendous response for the demo stall. Unlike many stalls that had just put some computers and explained the concept, we had actually put the artworks (framed) and even sold the artworks to show them how this entire thing works. We had put up a Flash presentation explaining our concept in a Dell laptop and also a gallery showing our artworks in a MAC computer. This is the closest we are able to go to the real business. Some 7 people purchased artworks there and we got some 4-5 bulk order expression of interest. Many people who visited the stall liked the innovativeness of the concept. The beauty about this idea is that though the concept we are selling looks very simple, the thought process behind designing this concept is very complex. It involves all the economic principles present. I believe if this concept works, it creates a disruption in the art industry. We strive to make it work and we need all your support to make it work. 

Here are some pictures from the event -

Art as an investment

I, at times (infact many times) wonder how art got this tag "Investment Product" and why art is very expensive. I think it is the work of selected few in the medevial Europe that led to the current pitiful state of Art Industry. I strongly believe art is a common man's product. Art needs appreciation and artist needs recognition. A person who can appreciate art needn't be a rich person and a rich person needn't particularly like or appreciate art. But the current industry structure is so that only rich is able to purchase art and majority of that rich is purchasing art more for a status symbol than for anything else. My neighbour has it, I should have it!! - As simple as that. The galleries promote art saying it is an investment product. I again believe that art can never be a popular investment. Here are the reasons why:

1. Price Discovery: Every investment product requires price discovery. Price of that product should be same at any particular time in any particular region irrespective of person purchasing or buying it. This happens through a basic economic principle called 'Demand - Supply'. If demand outstrips supply, price increases and otherwise. But in the case of art, till date there is no mechanism for finding the value of art. Nobody is able to give me a convincing answer on price discovery of artwork. An artist looks at a person and quotes a price. If i come in Benz, his price will be high otherwise his price will be low. In this kind of situation, no investment product survives. Investment requires market mechanised price discovery which art lacks...

2. Liquidity:  Another major requirement for investment product is liquidity. Liquidity means how quickly one can purchase or sell the product. If i need money, i should be able to sell my investment product and raise money immediately and if i want to buy investment product, i should be able to buy it immediately. Stock, Real Estate, Bonds, Derivatives, Swaps, Futures - all are liquid products. But art is not. I can't just go to an exchange (in the first place there is no art exchange), sell art and get money. It is extremely illiquid. It takes years and years to get the artwork sold. 

3. Regulatory Body: Every investment product requires a regulatory body that puts rules and checks whether rules are well followed. In fact, all major investment products have regulatory bodies like SEBI. They ensure that trading is happening as per rules. But in the case of art, there is no regulatory body. I was surprised to hear from artists that art galleries facilitate price fixing. A body profiting from art sale is also regulating it!!!!!! Galleries form cartel it seems and fix the price of artist. So, they effectively increase the price of artist or his artwork artifically. It is not the inherent value of artwork, it is the gallery's greed to make money that is increasing the price of artworks. This is the biggest offence to be committed in an investment product class.  

4. Availability of information: An investment product requires free availability of information for people to make a decision. Companies, Governments all publish their financial information so that people can decide whether to buy that bond or stock or Real Estate. This helps in finding the true value of investment product. But in the case of art, information is very scarcely available. No artist publish his progress in career on a regular basis. The buyer should check out the artist progress and has to hard sell that information to another prospective buyer to make a sale.  

5. Steady stream of income: An investment product should ensure a steady stream of income to the investment product holder like say Dividends, Rentals, Interest....But art doesn't provide any steady stream of revenue for  the art holder. The art collector can't make money out of the artwork he has. It is just used to decorate the house.

6. Art for display: Finally, all other investment products are not for display. Like say, stocks, bonds and land - you can't use those to decorate the house where as art is used to decorate the house and display your aesthetic sense. So, art effectively is a consumer product that is somehow projected as an investment product. And this led the art industry into a huge rut. When you see a highly creative artist struggling to make ends meet, you understand how pitiful the state of industry is.. 

By all means, art is not an investment product as people projected it. Art can be considered an auction product. Scarcity of the work is the one that should increase the price like any other auction product (Gandhi spectacles, blue diamond).

Now who is losing because of that tag 'Art is an investment'. Rich people aren't as for them the amount paid is nothing. Middle class & upper middle class also aren't as they refrain from buying art. For them it is expensive. So ultimately it is the artist who is losing. A quick study at the situation of artists explain it clearly. Artists are effectively catering to 1% of the market (the rich and elite) out of which only 20% may buy art and that gets spread across many artists. An artist can sell a maximum of 10 artworks a year and can earn some 2  - 3 laks maximum per year. And he should keep on creating new works irrespective of whether those get sold or not. So, there is a huge dead inventory in an artist house. A 90% dead inventory is the worst situation in any industry. There should be a way to mobilize that dead inventory and monetize that. DAW is actually targeting that market and is trying to mobilize that dead inventory and monetize it while making artworks affordable to common man. 

I hope and sincerely wish artists understand my concept and encourage me that just think i am decreasing the value of their artworks (which i amn't doing as we are purchasing digital rights and these are very different from original rights).We are still facing a tough time as many artists are confined to this thought process of 'art as investment'. Some are getting convinced and many aren't. So, we aren't able to implement the concept exactly the way we wanted to at this point. I hope this one becomes success and artists understand that our true intention is to create additional revenue channel for them than just take their works for cheap and make money. 

Adios

Raja Sekhar

CEO

Digital Art Works

www.digitalartworks.in

Digital Art Works Launched

After 2 months of tiresome work, we finally brought Digital Art Works into a proper shape. I am highly satisfied with the way the application turned out. Today we got the payment gateway access and integrated it to the Digital Art Works website. Now t is a fully functional website except for some data we have to enter from the back end. We will be launching it officially on March 10th with a  press conference in Hyderabad. Till then we will be testing the product and also will be fine tuning the supply chain, marketing and operations part of it.

About DAW (Digital Art Works):

For those who don't know about DAW, here is a brief write up about the product. Stating it all in one line - 'Digital Art Works is into affordable global art'. When someone mentions art, the first that comes to our minds is that it is an esoteric product which is very expensive and which is only for rich people. But should it be so? An experience i had at CEIBS when my friend gifted me a piece of art costing around 1000/- proved it otherwise. I liked the work a lot and started asking myself this question. And the end result is the metamorphisation of Haofresh into Digital Art Works and shift from selling t-shirts with designs into selling just art pieces at an affordable price. We use a concept called 'Digital Rights' and 'Digital Reproduction' to bring down the cost of artworks so that even middle class can also afford it.

The journey till date was extremely tough for the entire Kriya Media team. The art industry is a well established niche industry catering to the rich and elite. And now we are kind of challenging that and many are raising up their defences against us. There is a preconceived notion that artwork should be expensive. We found it so hard to convince the artists that they can earn more by selling at a lower cost. For an artist, lowering down the price is like losing his self esteem. AND IT IS TRUE. Many artists are ready to forego income but aren't ready to lower the prices. I at times find it absurd and irrational but that is how the industry works. It is always the question of scale or price.

But history is replete with examples like this wherein a niche product is commoditised with immense success..A classic one being Cars - Before Henry Ford started Ford Motor Company, automobiles were always for the rich and elite..But Ford changed the way industry functioned. And then computers. Before DELL started selling through his Direct to dell model, IBM was selling at a very high price. Even this space tourism, Richard Branson is trying to bring it with in the reach of common man. Having set our aspirations against these previous cases, we are embarking on this journey to commoditize art. Hope , with all the God's grace, this works out well.

Adios

Raja Sekhar

CEO, Kriya Media.

DAW: Trend setter

Nilesh Kulkarni wanted to decorate his new home in Hyderabad and his search included celebrated names in the industry. He was in a desperate need of buying some art works for this pongal. He discussed with his wife and the duo decided to wait for sometime as they couldn't get what they wanted. Many people like Nilesh were on the lookout for more appealing master pieces.

The wait for quality images is over with the setting up of Digital Art Works. Digital Artworks devotes time, effort and intuition of every artist at the same level. Digital Artworks is the product of Kriya Media Solutions, a budding global digital media company. DAW is committed to see that no single artist is denied access to showcase his aesthetic sense for want of resources. DAW engages in constant research on painting themes, artists' galleries, painting styles and related information. It is DAW's endeavor to serve the artists and public who have inclination for artworks and creative styles in depicting core ideas of this magnificent nature.

What can an artist expect from DAW?

DAW put designs and paintings selected from various artists on our web page. Based on the quality and intensity of the expressionism, naturalism and realism (other modes are rare) they get ratings from users. Once the due date closes, ratings and comments given to the artworks  are evaluated and the best master piece will be chosen. The owner of the master piece gets the reward.

What can people expect from DAW?

Digital Art Works team works full time in getting top quality pictures for minimum prices. No other group is able to find this mechanism till date. DAW team leaves no stone unturned for searching valuable information and for creating awareness amongst the commoners. Digital Artworks is started with a vision to accommodate every naturally gifted artist to have his own class in the field of artworks creations. DAW is firm about creating level playing field for each and every artist class. It is our policy to see that every single intellectual drop behind every creation, small or big, rich or economic class, general interest or abnormally intuitive, is given its due.

DAW conducts seminars, workshops on promoting congenial environment for artists and publish the same on our site. DAW team attracts designs and master pieces to put them for rating where in top rated designs get their reward. HR people at DAW visit art galleries and try to unleash the artist's mind. The T-shirt division identifies current market trends and gives best input on creating T-shirts and making it big in that industry too.

Anyone who thinks he is naturally gifted can directly approach the organization. DAW welcomes every enthusiast to go and search our blogs and designer interviews, rating and pricing of artworks, and solicit visitors valuable feedback. There are many interesting things on the site. Videos, Photos, designer interviews etc,. are provided for creating interest.

Now that the wait is over with the onset of online community on digital arts, Nilesh and his wife are a happy lot as they are inch closer to decorating their new home with different painting themes and styles. DAW is set to create new trends, thanks to the innovators!